Look, before continuing with this video, I’ll show you all contradictions we’ve been living these days so surrealistic. Before that, I’d like to make a comment. I am catalan, catalan parents. I was a separatist and most of my friends were separatists. And what independentism is about: hatred against everything Spanish. We’ve been made to believe that we are better than others just because we’re Catalan and separatist. I was lucky to realise that I was fooled and, when I got away from separatism, I saw how you get socially excluded. Since then, I’ve made some videos you can watch here, explaining how the Catalan institutions have been manipulating us. With the hope of making other catalonians to wake up from deception. I’ve managed to open the eyes to some of them, but I am aware that currently, seeing there are so many separatists justifying violence and breaking the Law, is almost impossible to change these people’s minds. They’ve become fanatics. So my efforts go towards the youngest, so they have a different narrative than that of separatism in Catalonia. Where children are indoctrinated from schools, their own parents and continuing with tv3, the catalan public tv. We have hundreds of examples. Here you can see how they use children in demonstrations as if they were funny children’s games (Children in a separatist demonstration) A mother pushing into her daughter’s mind the idea that she doesn’t live in a free country. Who can say what are you doing here? Who can explain?
What’s your name? -Caral Why have you come here to give your support, with your parents? To demand the freedom of Catalonia. And here a TV channel interviewing children who take independence as a party. “I come to fight for the independence of Catalonia.” “I am independentist and I want Catalonia to be a free country.” “Because in 1714 we stopped being independent.” “If so many Catalonians want it, Spain will have to surrender and we’ll have independence.” “We want, we want independence!” And here a school that puts children to sing “Free political prisoners” And here another school teaching them how to hate Spain, from very young age -“The Catalans are in rebelion against Spain!” -“As a king, I have to end this rebelion”. -“All those defending it, will die!” -“Ermengol, I have ready the gunpowder.” -(Teacher hushes) “We’re going to destroy the Spanish army.” “We’re going to destroy the Spanish army.” No, they aren’t anecdotal cases, there are many more examples. See what this mother said about what her daughter, studying in a school in Catalonia told her: “Look how bad the situation is, when she came home one day telling me that I should change my name, as it sounds too Spanish!” And now someone will come to say that I am lying. “It’s a lie, you’re lying”… Look, I’ve lived this myself, how when I played a Paco de Lucía song to a 10 years old relative, when she asked me if he was Spanish (curious she asked that), I said yes, and she did like this: And these are only some of the examples. The indoctrination in Catalonia is a machine to create separatists. Even they indoctrinate foreign refugees “Eduard is an educator of young inmigrants, so criminalized lately. They are here, we can’t speak with them because they are minors.” “To demand the freedom for Catalonia.” “Come to fight for the independence of Catalonia.” We’ve made them understand that they’re are in a country that isn’t Morocco, that we’re in Europe,
that is a free country, where we can demonstrate freely. They told me in Morocco they have a king, that is a dictator, that all people are against him,
and that it’s the same situation as it is in Spain now. That’s why they empathyse with us, but of course, this in their country would be impossible.
They are 100% from Morocco. Please turn around to show the flags…
They show separatist flags, and Berber flags, and here they are, supporting the cause. In my book “Spain from the bar” in the page 437 you have an example of a girl who explains how being 20 years old, without a clue of Catalan History, she came to Spain to live she is Czech, and ends up having a separatist boyfriend with separatist family, and after some years she believes Franco brought Spaniards in trains to colonise Catalonia, that Andalusians are lazy -not knowing anything about Andalusia- and of course, she became separatist. By the way, she ended up marrying a Turk, and now lives in Turkey. In the end separatists have the wrong idea of what freedom is… The former football player Xavi, who works in Qatar, said that Qatar is not a democracy, but it works better than Spain Well well the separatists defending Qatar… Qatar has an absolute monarchy, no democracy, and it’s easy to see many separatists demonstrating for freedom with tee shirts of Barça, supporting Qatar. They are the kings of hypocrisy! Wait, and now I remember that one of the lays for the “new country” that Puigdemont prepared, only one person prepared this law in Europe: Hitler. Not only designating the judges, but those judges can’t stop any of the decrees that the president, while they start the laws for their new republic. Nobody, even Putin or Erdogan dared to do such thing. Only Hitler with his Enabling Law. This is explained by the independentist that made up the phrase “Spain steals us”, who is against this independence now. And this was said also in the Catalan parlament. Look: “It isn’t true that we don’t want to debate, we are just asking you to respect the Law. To respect out rights. The Council of Statutory Warranty is telling you so. What you’re doing is very serious.
One question: who would you say is an authorised voice you won’t ignore about which things can be done and which can’t? The Parlament. Mr President of Generalitat, we’re getting into a very difficult situation. If someone has to explain the president of Catalan Generalitat that the majority of a parlament cannot approve laws that trample on citizens’ rights recognised in the Constitution; if one has to explain to the president of the parlament that he cannot sabotage the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia; if someone has to explain this to the president of Catalonia, the least of our concerns is the referendum, or the law of legal transitoriness. It means we have a very very serious problem.” And yet, having explaining it a thousand times with thousand arguments, separatists come out sharing photos in the separatist strike, saying that they want freedom and they’re making history. “And I loved the amount of people during the 6 hours walking the slow walk till we arrived to Barcelona and the amount of grannies that peeked out and saluted us and thanked us for fighting for the freedom of Catalan people. And I tell you, it’s wonderful the power of mobilisation that we’re having this week…” Look, look at this girl, how she fights for her freedom, look how little freedom the poor girl has, how oppressed she clearly is, with her breasts asking for freedom. Keep on going. If you continue like this you’ll be remembered as the village idiots. This march that she and separatists love so much and grannies greet, was organised by a terrorist called Carles Sastre, which was sentenced to 48 years of prison for murder -he only served 11 years- and now he organises their political strikes for “freedom”, that freedom the man he murdered can’t have. You are a bunch of hypocrites! Hipocrytes that will still make History as nazis and ku kux klan members made it. Look how they demonstrate as you do, making History, how can so many people join and be wrong? It cannot be! They are peaceful people. “We are the people” say separatists, and so nazis said. Look here how separatist students want to close the access to University saying they are “the people”. “We comply only the laws that suit us, right?” “Don’t pay attention to what the people or the students say” “Listen, we are also the people” -“Show us if that’s true”
“If you were the people you would be here, and not there” “Ok then, there I go” “Come, come here” “Come on boys, we ask you not to be violent. You haven’t come here to talk, you’ve come to press us.” “That’s correct, we are the people!!” Separatists, don’t you realise that you share the same ideas as the nazis and the ku kux klan? Segregate! Ones segregate blacks, other segregate jews and you segregate Spaniards. And you even copy nazi laws and their style, “Woow what are you saying?” Ok, look at this All with torches: here the ku kux klan, here the nazis, here the separatists. Not sure which is which, as they look the same, you know? Am I right? these are the separatists, these are the nazis, aren’t they? And wait! The separatists will jump on me saying they aren’t nazis, that nazis are these people. This is a real photo that they sent me. And THIS is the problem in this society, that History wasn’t taught, and what’s taught is manipulated. And they believe that nazis had tattoos and dressed in uniforms like this scum… and no. Nazis dressed like any regular person. Do you see this nice guy with the fishind rod? well, he was the main nazi in charge of exterminating people. Do you see the girl all pretty? she’s another nazi that followed nazism till her last days, because she was the daughter of the other guy. And this one, so happy looking, Irma Grese a nazi who killed women and children. But while we create idiots in the schools those idiots don’t know that you don’t need to be in uniforms or doing the fascist salute. The worst nazis are those who don’t look like nazis. Like the separatists. To be nazi isn’t about where your arm is, but about an attitude, that the separatists follow to the very detail: “Do you believe that the Catalans of PP and Ciudadanos aren’t part of the Catalan people?”
-“No” -“No… I don’t believe so.” “Can you imagine who could say such things?” -“No…” -“Let me show you:” “Our enemy is the State of Spain we must have this very clear. and the Spanish parties in Catalonia, like Ciudadanos and the Partido Popular. that sould be called not “Partido Popular of Catalonia”, but “Partido Popular IN Catalonia”. Those are our enemies. The rest, are the people of Catalonia. And the rest is who will achieve the independence.” This woman was the president of Catalan Parlament. “But the nazis killed people, how you dare to compare?” Yes, and the catalan separatists with Terra Lliure also killed. And the nazis before getting to the extreme of killing people they followed the same steps as the separatists, segregate telling who’s “the people” and who is not. Also, they’re already killing us socially, to those against independentism. They boycott you, making your life a living hell. But pay attention, it’s very easy to tell who acts like a separatist nazi. For example You’ll see them giving people licenses of who’s the Catalan people and who isn’t, and lately they make it easier, as they don’t discriminate between Catalonians and Spaniards. Now they discriminate between Catalans and delinquents. Like this guy: “For those who don’t live in Catalonia, those are the Catalans, not the brainless ones that you see in the riots on TV. Are you sure?? “Politicians deny all this. They say we are infiltrated, that we are violent groups. But they don’t want to go the root of the problem. To see what’s going on…” Now it seems that perfect Catalan they speak better than anyone, they have learnt it on their way to Catalonia they must be infiltrated people from Madrid. But don’t call them fascists, call them “radicals” just in case they are Catalan in the end. You can imagine that if what they’re doing, burn the streets, throwing stones, etc. was done by what they call “fascists” then they would say “fascist Spain occupies the streets”. But no, they are “radicals” acting in “self defense”. But hey, no, they’re infiltrated… My bald Spanish balds are infiltrated! Even in the public Catalan TV they say they’re NOT infiltrated… and TV3 is an 100% pro-separatist channel. Pay attention: “Could you find out who’s behind these actions, these hooded commandos? The hooded people are demonstrators. I know there’s an urban legend about infiltrated commandos, Italian, Dutch or German anarchists… but they have a nice Catalan accent from the Osona county. People that have been living here for long time, that are from here, that work here.”
-I have to cut you here, we’ll be back, we can’t hear you well due to delay…” They are ignorant young people that never lived ETA’s terrorism. and they believe they can achieve things using violence. You won’t see many adults in the riots burning down our cities, because separatists are well off, they are accommodated people who use the school kids to do the dirty job Here you have conversations of mothers defending their children who went to fight. And when the adults want to demonstrate, they do it from the Liceo, one of the most exclusive Opera theaters. These separatist snobs don’t want to negotiate this is a fight for power to see who’s stronger in Catalonia. They control the institutions, mass media and education, but since they can’t dominate the rest of Spain, they decided to break the Laws to do a trial of strength with the rest of Spain. Now using real violence. Till now they used psychological violence against those who weren’t separatists. Example: if you try to point out what they’re doing wrong, they block you, they expel you from their circles. It’s impossible to have a dialog. Their dialogs consist in “tell me I am right or you’re a fascist”. Period. In all this mess, the smartest politician was Artur Mas. He was the clever evil one who sparked the fire, who proposed independence to cover up for his party’s corruption and blackmail the State in order to achieve more money. He was followed by a herd of idiots, that even himself admitted they have fucked it up. And now he appears on TV3 to defend police in a moment when all the independentists criticise policemen. So imagine how much he knows he’s fucked it up. “Police (mossos) are doing what they have to do. The mossos aren’t monks”. -“What does it mean?” -“The mossos are police. What I mean is that you can’t pretend that Police acts in a way… how to say?… friendly. Sometimes the Police uses the violence against violence.” If you analyse globally their intervention, the pressure they suffer, and who they have in front, they’re doing well. And we must say it, and they must feel supported. At this point, those who support this movement that does strikes organised by murderers, we can only say that they’re idiots, and when I watch these interviews, they give me the reason: “There was fire and burnt containers and all. But I also say, in these areas there weren’t any problems. There weren’t any problems until police appeared. I understand that seeing burning containers isn’t the best image. I agree, nobody wants to see this, and less in your city, in your country, or anywhere, ok, but as I said, the problems appear when police shows up.” So it seems like burning cars and turning the city upside down is self defense, and when Police come to enforce order, they’re evil. Look, in Catalonia the politicians were so busy making sure we learnt Catalan in the schools, so they forgot to educate in common sense. But hey, now the president of Catalonia, Torra, will come up to fix things up: “We demand the Government of Spain to open immediately the negotiations for a political and democratic solution. We thank the Catalonians their democratic strength. We’ll go as far as the people of Catalonia want to go.” Torra few days ago:
Man: “My father would start a violent uprising” Torra: “Well, shall start it after the sentences. That is the moment.” Man: “But you keep suspending it” Torra: “No, we aren’t” Man: “In a year we’ll still be here. And in 1, in 2 and in 30.” Torra: “No, man. Trust. Trust and hope.” Let’s see, Torra and company. We already had a legal referendum in 2015 that was called plebiscite, and you lost. But yet you broke the law and declared independence, and you don’t realise that now, seeing how totalitarian you are the only margin for negotiation is to tell you that your autonomous government is suspended in Catalonia because you are so irresponsible? Don’t you see that every step you take is more destructive and illegal. Because it’s the same all the evidences you show, they make up lies, it’s frustrating the level of mind manipulation they suffer. And I would like to say that I am not against those who support independence. I am against this separatist movement. There are separatists who are intelligent and they’ve left the movement. Independentists who want independence from an economic point of view, but not who follows this xenophobic madness, where they believe they live in Franco times. Please. Their minds have been so manipulated that they believe they live in Franco’s times. Look this is a note from a school that says that they go on strike to protest against the sentence and against the “franquist repression”. It’s madness!! The separatists who remain are fanatics and the teenagers are manipulated into hatred, forgetting that what they do only leads to destruction. In schools and on TV they aren’t taught to build, they’re taught to destroy. They don’t know what is like, being 15 and enjoy one of the most democratic countries in the world. And who doesn’t believe this, pay attention to these 12 years old kids blocking a road in the night. This is like the children play in Catalonia, the tradition or blocking roads. If we have reached this extreme, 12 ears old kids blocking roads in the night, is due to irresponsible idiots, and that’s why the answer to the title of this video: “Why do they want independence?” It’s very simple: because they are IDIOTS. By the way, this was my initial consideration to explain how we got this far with all this violence in our streets… and I believe it has taken me a bit too long….. Anyway, thanks everyone… I am Joan Planas and here ends El Recomendador, and remember. Don’t break the Law, or Police will come and get you in jail. Enjoy life!