What’s wrong with spiritual gurus being rich? – Sadhguru answers Nalsar student

What’s wrong with spiritual gurus being rich? – Sadhguru answers Nalsar student


It is a common notion among people that spirituality
is a rich person’s area. So even if you look at the people who have
gathered around here, we’re all pretty much well off, and once we have earned for ourselves,
we then find time to do yoga, or meditation, or look into our inner being. But as we discussed all through… throughout
the whole discussion till now – there are… yes, you yourself have said that five-hundred
million people are still malnourished and there are so many people in this country who
are daily-wage workers who… who at that point of time, spirituality and learning of
their inner being would not there…would not be the most important thing for them. Their most important thing would be feeding
themselves and their children for the next meal. Sadhguru: Really you think so? You do one thing. You go to any so called spiritual event in
the country, will you see rural masses there or people like you in denims? (Applause) Who will you see, hmm? Questioner 3: Yeah, yeah… Sadhguru: So, don’t make conclusions which
are not even true. Are we trying to prove something or are we
trying to look at truth? The truth of this nation is, we have kept
our populations in extreme abject poverty. Nourishment is missing, leave anything else,
nourishment is missing. In spite of that… I must tell you this, people ask me these
questions wherever I go in the world, “Sadhguru, so many spiritual teachers and masters, so
many great beings have come in India but why are we so poor? Why is India so poor? Where is the spirituality?” Well, you know this. Two-hundred-and-fifty years ago we were the
richest nation on the planet. Everybody wanted to come to India. Why do you think a Vasco da Gama or that Columbus
who made that mistake, all these people set off in the oceans that they did not know and
over hundred expedition… expeditions in the ocean drowned, nobody ever wrote about
them, all right – because nobody writes about people who drown in the oceans. So, why was everybody in Europe trying to
come to India? Because it was the most prosperous nation. Well, in two-hundred-and-fifty years we got
cleaned up, we can’t… well, somebody did it to us because we can’t
just blame them because it is also ourselves who allowed that thing to happen to ourselves. Now we are trying to build back, all right? But even though you kept them in such abject
poverty, wherever these people went, they made sure not a bit of the local culture remained. Just look at North America, South America,
Australia and large parts of Africa, anywhere, this one culture, after thousand years of
invasions, we’ve still kept our culture and our spiritual process – not for nothing! Where we are, you know, where our yoga center
is, there is a police station about twelve kilometers away. This police station is supposed to service
nearly a quarter million people in different levels of economic situations, all right? Some are rich farmers, some are medium, some
are really poor, there are tribal communities, everything. There are only (Sounds like – to/till?)
now… in the last thirty years I’ve been there, at a time there was only seven, eight
policemen with a ASI (Referring to assistant sub-inspector of police). Today, there are about fourteen to fifteen
policemen with a SI – this is an upgrade that happened three years ago. Otherwise, even now, with these fourteen policemen
two or three will be on leave because of something or the other, and three, four are on night
duty. Hardly seven, eight policemen for quarter
million people, and these are poor people living in small huts. People are driving in Mercedes cars up and
down but they never pounced on them, killed them and took what they have. It never happened. This is spirituality if you’ve not… if
you’ve forgotten this, this is spirituality (Applause), you understand? Well, you don’t stretch this too far, you
don’t take their spirituality fo… too far. You have to settle what they need in their
lives as quickly as possible otherwise they won’t hold for too long. But it is because of that spiritual process
we as a nation have survived in spite of all the abuse that’s happened to us and don’t
say rural masses don’t have spirituality, they are the ones who are really on, urban
masses are losing it, isn’t it? Questioner: No, my question wasn’t towards
rural masses, mine is like… Sadhguru: No, poor… Questioner: … for example, I’ll just… Sadhguru: Poverty, right? Questioner: Not… not poverty as such but
for people who are working every day, like for example the maid in my house, for example,
she let’s say she works in five-six different houses, she probably is able to make 4000,
5000 a month and at that point of time she would try to… the most important thing going
in her mind would be educating her children, probably feeding herself. I am saying that they do deserve to… Sadhguru: Yes. Questioner: …have the self-awareness and
the spirituality but how… how will we… Sadhguru: Okay, how will we do it? If you do not know this – seventy percent
of our work is in rural India, where the poorest of the poor are, okay? Poorest of the poor are in rural India, seventy
percent of our work is in rural India and it’s free. It’s free of cost. You walk with me in Tamil Nadu – you go into
a village, the entire village will gather not for money, not for something else because
they know there is (are?) some tools of transformation which they can make use of. So, in the city there is money involved simply
because you want it in a air-conditioned room. Air-conditioning is on right now, whether
I pay or you pay or somebody else pays, somebody is paying for it, isn’t it? If you don’t understand this, you have no
sense of economy. That’s a biggest problem in the country
– people have no sense of economy so they are always asking for welfare schemes, “Give
me this, give me that.” But whether I pay or you pay, somebody is
paying, isn’t it? If what is paid is not accounted for, it’s
not going to work. This is the reason why we are poor because
we are not conducting our economics properly. Now spiritual process is about inner strength
– especially if (Sounds like – we/you?) are going through hardships, inner strength
is most important or no? That is the time to remove it. Is it there for the rural masses? Definitely there, much more than… Seventy percent of our time we are investing
but when I come to the city, when I come to Delhi, activists come and invite me, “Why
are you only meeting the rich and powerful? Why are you not coming to the slum?” I said, “The whole goddamn country is a
slum and I’m traveling all over. When I come to Delhi I want to meet only the
rich and powerful, let it be very clear to you. I’m not going to come to the slum in Delhi
because the entire country is a slum if you’ve not seen.” Moderator: So this is a question we were sent. And the context of this question as I understand
is that previously our understanding of gurus or mystics were individual… individuals
who meditated and were in penance in forests (Sadhguru laughs), who were not attached to… I mean who are not attached or concerned with
businesses. So a question we were sent is that now we
see a lot of mystic individuals who have huge foundations, who have companies. Some of whom who have gone into production
of foods and soaps. So, the question here is that is this… Sadhguru: Toothpaste… That’s the most popular (Laughter). Moderator: So the question here is that, is
this a healthy trend that you have individuals who you otherwise identified as individuals,
devoid of material pleasures, or away from material pleasures, or away from businesses
are now actually turning to them? Sadhguru: Well, you have not yet managed a
business. Managing a business is definitely not a pleasure
(Laughs), okay? But I know who is in the focus right now (Laughter). See, I was (Laughs)… I had a… some kind of a conference in Chennai. And somebody came to pick me up and the driver
was driving. He’s a regular driver. He goes behind what is in front of him. And it’s getting late. I have a reputation to keep, that in these
thirty-seven years I have not been late to a single event in my life (Applause). Though in one day I may have three, four,
five events, still I have not been late to one. So I want to get there. This guy is going at his own pace in the traffic. So I said, “You get out” and I took the
wheel, and I did some force driving. That was in Tamil Nadu. The Andhra Pradesh police cannot do anything
about it (Laughter). So I did some force driving and just made
it in time. The security gate at the hotel, you know these
days they are stopping you, opening your bonnet, checking your engine and your boot. Nobody knows what they are looking for (Laughter). After that… After that Mumbai event, unfortunately everybody
has to go through this. So the car in front of me went and the gate
opened. I just went through and they were screaming. I came into the portico, stopped, left the
car there and ran into the conference. There was some journalist standing there. After I finished the thing and I came back,
they said, “In ancient times yogis, used to walk (Few laugh). You drive your own car, what kind of a yogi
are you?” Then I said, “You idiot, in ancient times,
everybody was walking (Laughter/Applause). Not just a yogi.” So… Moderator: So mystics keep with the times? Sadhguru: Hmm? Moderator: So mystics keep with the times? Sadhguru: Oh, they were always contemporary
(Laughter). The problem… The problem is most people’s idea of a mystic
is the Sivakasi calendar (Few laugh), where one man is sitting under the tree with a constipated
look on his face (Laughter). That is a calendar art. That is not a mysticism, all right? The mystics of the day… Well, look at anybody. If you call Krishna a mystic, he was working
with the kings all the time because he wanted to transform the political system. If you see Gautama Buddha, always working
with the kings, because he wants to transform the political system. Without transforming the political system,
people will not benefit. So always, the gurus were always around the
kings not because of their palaces, because of their concern – unless the one who rules
transforms himself, there will be no benefit for the people. Right from ages, you go back wherever you
want – always they were around the kings not looking for crumbs in the palace but simply
because unless you transform that one fool, the country will not change (Applause).

100 Comments on "What’s wrong with spiritual gurus being rich? – Sadhguru answers Nalsar student"


  1. Shame on you NALSAR ! If this is the genre of students you have, you must review your selection procedures and ask yourself, where did you go wrong! Absolutely arrogant, ignorant fools who will screw the judiciary at some point! Pls get them some basic breathing exercises before you even start with their daily academic schedule. They might not be become Buddha but they will become better human beings.

    Reply

  2. 250 years ago India was in the hands of Mughals
    He speaks nourishment and jumped into spirituality
    Sir, can you please explain what are you doing for the poor
    What the breathing techniques will do to the poor

    Reply

  3. For monetary excess to exist, it must come at the cost of monetary deprivation in one point of the procedure or the process would not make any sense whatsoever. In condoning monetary excess, therefore common sense would stipulate somebody along the change is deprived of some monetary ownership.. It is not possible to have global monetary excess that is not how the wheels of Capitalism work…Being wealthy is just another term for Capitalism… Therefor to deprive somebody of wealth in order to gain spiritual Enlightenment creates a victim ..Hardly the essence of spiritual Guru-ism..This is why we need to be real about the the fact a service is being provided…People flock to a Guru as it is an easy fix for a life long Spiritual search for their truth.. A programme of truth is simply that, somebody else giving their opinion and sharing it..Popularity makes them a Guru.. Answers are provided for those that don't have the answers, as he stipulated before,,,In that I agree but how hard have people looked for the answer ? Everybody is entitled to their own vision and way of thinking. I just can't abide the Guru terminology. We can learn from each other no matter how long a person has been on a spiritual path,

    Reply

  4. a man in hungry cannot focus on meditation/ praying/ spiritual . That is the reason why, in all Hindu temples Prasadam is provided

    Reply

  5. I better not start watching his videos before the bed time. I keep watching them and never go to bed. So addictive to listen to him. I don't think even crystal ball will be so clearer than his answers.

    Reply

  6. Anybody can possess wealth. But spirituality is about not being attached to what you have.

    Reply

  7. pathetic behaviour…one cannot expect such ill mannered folks to be our country's future generation.Just being a student of NALSAR won't bring some prestige, you must possess moral values.Such egoistic fellas…

    Reply

  8. 00:01, 11:34 — could someone point to the whole version of this musical and rhythmical delight, please?

    Reply

  9. What kind of ambiance Nalsar university is providing. The university is full of idiots.

    Reply

  10. What is the difference between an asshole and a wise?
    Answer: A wise one always agrees with Sadhguru…!!! 👍👍

    Reply

  11. Being rich Is not bad. Nor it is good. Is simply is.
    Being rich just amplify how much you can help or how much damage you can make.
    If you are a good person it will allow you do more good.
    If you are an evil person, it will allow you to do more evil.
    If you are a normal person, neither good nor evil. it will allow you to live your life without caring what others think of you. You do things because you want to do them instead of doing them just to survive.

    Reply

  12. Idiot!!! its a lot of ego…e limitation!!!! read krisnamurti…..why you need gurus?! filas da puta pretensiosos

    Reply

  13. I do not understand, Sadhguru sees the guy is very emotional and does not address it. He knows that he is surrounded by Sadhguru`s followers and Joe is here alone. Joe raises a point. Clearly as a man, not woman, he tries to understand something and address his objection over discrimination of women.

    He is scared and emotional here.
    Mental Health Nurses spend three years training and learning to read from the tone of voice, behaviour, emotions whether the person arguing with us is in distress and speaks out of anger etc. Then we know that something upsets the person and our duty is to help and help ourselves as nurses to protect ourselves. That is why we use knowledge and training and when someone is in distress we acknowledge that, we do not argue or fight because the mind can not think or reflect when in distress.

    Limbic body (fight or flight) mode is disturbing. It is natural. It is nature. So we always tell the person and say to another person that we do not want to take the adventage of our position and knowledge and tell that it's better if we sit down and discuss the matter as equals. Without anger. Because then arguing will only harm both sides. And Sadhguru is calm, and tells easily his answers, but forgets to notice that the boy is in distress, so his arguments fell on deaf ears. did not help Joe neither him. Unless Sudhguru likes to preach to himself only.

    Reply

  14. Spirituality has its root in the Land and is given birth to by the people who work the Land, The farmer, the builders, the craftsmen of this World. Those in touch with Earth and Mother Nature understand Spirituality is born on the Wind to those who are not afraid of the Almighty Truth..This message is for everyone but only the brave and those with courage to confront their own Dark Nights alone and win are worthy…..A true Guru uses his donations and acquired riches to further the cause of mankind and feed the vulnerable and friendless of this shitty little existence..If this doesn't happen then society is destroyed from the root to the fruit and even the animals and plants and trees wail a song of misery and repentance for what did they do wrong that they have to suffer the sinful actions of all human beings??? Just what do they have to do with a Godless drama?? So the misuse of a symbol of exchange and trade which is nothing more than is. Is the root of all Evil.. One can buy the hungry food or take away their live at the point of a gun….Money in the right hands, everybody prospers, in the wrong hands we all starve!!!

    Reply

  15. Unless you transform that one Fool, 🤣we know who all! Sadhguru spontaneous wit sat nails!

    Reply

  16. I'd say absolutely nothing wrong with them being rich, if they're actually good at their job. Like Sadhguru is. Understand, these types of people are the ones who SHOULD be rich. And not all your scumbag politicians, corporate overlords, and banker filth. Let the good men be rich, and the scumbags live in poverty.

    Reply

  17. He meant it.
    Sadhguru answers it.
    .
    'but Sadhguru i didn't mean it!'

    Reply

  18. Money is a resource which allows you to get things done and not necessary that if I possess money because I have a craving for it

    Reply

  19. All spiritual gurus are rich. Fools following them and make them rich. Only educated fools blindly follow such people.

    Reply

  20. Money… Power… Followers… Luxury all this is possible by becoming a Yogi…
    In earlier days great kings gave up everything and realised life is short trip but today's sages they are good preachers with different Intentions within them…

    Reply

  21. I saw the entire talk with NALSAR school of lawyers. I was very impressed with Sadhguru's responses, but I kept uttering to myself that Sadhguru ask the individual what is their definition of Spirituality. Does this individual student consider spirituality as one who sits with their eyes closed and chants some mantra for hours or an individual who does seva for others? Because, in my opinion a kamwali bai who earns 4,000 – 6,000 rupees a month is doing work of spirituality, same as a person who is sitting with their eyes closed and chanting for hours.
    As far as the students being disrespectful, they are students of the law and their duty is to win the case based on their questions and arguments they present and these students were doing just their lawyers duty. Lawyers will use any means to get a rise out of you to win an argument, but it is the individual himself who has a choice to fall into the trap of the lawyer or rise above and channel the discussion to a higher level. Sadhguru took the route of channelling the discussion to a higher level, but the students didn't understand his answers that is their problem, not sadhguru's. 🙂

    Reply

  22. Monetary richness indicates less giving to the needy! This guy can never be a guru!

    This idiot, I have never seen him in slum areas or reassuring untouchables!!! A Swami or guru is suppose to help and console those who are suffering and who are in extreme bad conditions. Not morons like you listeners who are well off and make you happier!!! He is unfit to be a guru or Swami because he never talks about people who need philosophy and religious reassurances. He talks to smart students meets great people visits great places and has fun with great music. He is an sinful idiot guru. Jaggi is African tribal man! Truth hurts I know. It has energy. It has power. It stirs minds and enters once subconscious mind and brings subtle changes. That is why people are uncomfortable with my messages but they know it is true!!! And By doing so my role is justified. This idiot guru has been elevated to the heights that he doesn’t deserve. When you guys fall from him it will be free fall from Himalayas !!! Not Knowing full life history of a famous man who talks good and behaves like a nice man can be dangerous for getting bullied. Many famous gurus did that and finally were caught and went to jail.

    Reply

  23. I think the nalsar asked good question but they were too arrogant.
    They had assumed this is some another fake-baba making money. The questions and arrogance were coming from that assumptions.
    There are many astrologer and tantric people who use peoples emotion to earn their money and destroy the peoples home and relationships
    But sadhguru is the real fire.

    Reply

  24. From the first question Sadhguru insults all of India and the second question he doesn't even answer.

    He interrupts and uses humor to disarm the audience and take use of their foolishness.

    Reply

  25. Dear All , SADGURU is Just TOO MUCH for these NALSAR LAW Students to Handle !! He is making FOOLS of them 🤣😂🤣😂 . I JUST CAN'T STOP LAUGHING !!! Seshadri

    Reply

  26. The rich were once guru's themselves, every prince and noble had to know the religious scriptures and teachings of the church, this was to create a beneficial political system.

    Reply

  27. Even if they didn't agree with him, they could have been more respectful in their tone and the way they framed their questions. Very immature.

    Reply

  28. The whole motive to be a Guru , a holy man, a Baba or a missionary is to be rich.

    Reply

  29. Maid works in 4 or 5 houses and earn only 4000 or 5000 per month….think.. how much that guy or the family paid for her work…and Now he is talking about poor…

    Reply

  30. Had goosebumps literally. His thoughts just united our whole nation as one so beautifully, keeping spirituality and culture as it's foundation. Sadhguru redefining yoga every single day. 🙏

    Reply

  31. Few more such interviews and NALSAR will not have any students joining it. NALSAR students are the worst brand ambassadors for the School.

    Reply

  32. This is so TRUE! My god! If you can’t transform that one mind it will remain in hell creating hell for others…

    Reply

  33. Gurus are forced to change.They are contemporary.modernity transform them.They are not transforming people. Corporates
    are shrewd to commercialise this
    area of people's quest for peace and spirituality.Any how good this has become big industry.Attending
    this kind of events is an elevation
    for their vanity

    Reply

  34. Spirituality is not identical with poverty. Yes , there are many spiritual gurus live in poverty. But it is so because they have to experience their certain karmic consequences.

    Spirituality , full balanced life should indentic with abundance, wealth. If you do not have wealth, then there is lacking , something missing in your sadhana.

    Reply

  35. Kama is to be sacrificed in favour of Artha.
    Artha is to be sacrificed for Dharma and Artha is to be used to serve Dharma.
    Dharma is the tree that gives the fruits of Kama and Artha and leads to Moksha.
    The roots of Dharma must be firmly planted in spirituality and in morality.

    Reply

  36. I was brought up in a christian church school that taught me money is evil. The Bible was edited in order to keep people in poverty. It is hard to then change your belief system as an adult to accept that this is a lie poverty is the evil and that there is spiritual and material abundance.

    Reply

  37. haha I remember once one of Ghandi's helpers said, "It takes A LOT of MONEY to keep Ghandi POOR!!! " think about that

    Reply

  38. Why become Gods person to become rich. God does not require any money. Ofcourse anything fo with accumulating wealth does not become a Godly man. Onky selfish people accumulate wealth. Spiritual people do work for the benefit and give everything what they have to benefit the poor. I am sure if Sadhguru gives everything 5p feed the poor it's still not enough. But it will help many people to get rid of hunger. Being spiritual Is giving away and keeping what he actually deserve.

    Reply

  39. Why become Gods person to become rich. God does not require any money. Ofcourse anything fo with accumulating wealth does not become a Godly man. Onky selfish people accumulate wealth. Spiritual people do work for the benefit and give everything what they have to benefit the poor. I am sure if Sadhguru gives everything 5p feed the poor it's still not enough. But it will help many people to get rid of hunger. Being spiritual Is giving away and keeping what he actually deserve.

    Reply

  40. The comments section is a textbook example of fanaticism.
    The students asked something.. The fans of the guru go crazy as if the students committed a crime.

    Reply

  41. I have no idea why people asking stupid questions instead become student and ask questions to gain knowledge.

    Reply

  42. Also Swami Vivekananda tried to transform Kings/rulers.
    Namaskarm Sadhguru
    You are doing very well.

    Reply

  43. The shortest answer and most truth ever – Do you have a problem with Maa Laxmi visiting someone? Oooohh, be careful because immediately you will have a problem with Lord Vishnu! Then you ask for big trouble – it is your big EGO, so… a visit from Maa Kali is inevitable. Poor you then… very poor. And jealous – just to name it.

    Reply

  44. Thats the difference between true saint n fake guru~ the love for money ? Sadhguru has a personal wealth of US$40 MILLION. WHERES THE LOGIC.
    U cant have both.

    Reply

  45. When is Sat guru giving away his wordly wealth to poor. Talking and answering just for the sake of saying something is just a waste of time by this character Guru. He must declare his tax returns and if any amount his organization is evading. Spirituality and money should not mix if you are a genuine Guru.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *